English, social studies and special education teachers release open letter asking PAUSD board to reconsider reopening plan
This afternoon, English, social studies and special education teachers sent an open letter to Palo Alto Unified School District (PAUSD) Superintendent Don Austin, Associate Superintendent of Educational Services Sharon Ofek, Director of Secondary Education Services Kathie Laurence and the Board of Education urging reconsideration of the newly approved reopening plan. The letter, which was signed by 34 teachers, comes in response to the board’s Tuesday night decision to move forward with a reopening plan for middle and high schools. In it, teachers opposing the plan cite “misrepresentations” of information from the Tuesday night board meeting and outline rationales for reconsidering the current hybrid plan.
The plan will be “pedagogically unsound,” according to the letter. Furthermore, the letter points to the difficulties associated with having both the English and social studies departments adjust to in-person hybrid learning for second semester. “Navigating an entirely new hybrid process while still being asked to undertake the challenge of distance learning will stretch teachers too thin and be a disservice to our students,” the letter reads.
With reasons echoing community backlash to the plan from Tuesday night, the letter cites potential disruptions to educational consistency, class sizes, student-teacher relationships and the impact on Small Learning Communities, the Social Justice Pathway and special electives. It also expresses concerns about the viability of the hybrid classroom environment.
The letter also highlights the administration’s lack of transparency and questions the district’s decision-making process. “We should be a district that makes the hard decision to choose wisely, to choose reality over what is politically easy,” it reads. “We all want our hallways to ‘sound like school again,’ but the appearance of school is not the same as real public education—one committed to principles of equity—and we know that student learning is what matters most.”
Neither the administration nor the board has issued a response yet.
View the complete letter here.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Henry M. Gunn High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Senior Jessica Wang is the Editor-in-Chief of The Oracle 2021-2022. Outside of writing, you can find her creating a cappella arrangements for the Gunn...
Kerah Cottrell • Nov 14, 2020 at 12:02 pm
Bravo! I’m a Paly parent, and agree entirely. I applaud the effort and courage it took to compose this letter.
The hybrid plan is half-baked at best and will put students, teachers, and staff at risk. It will upset all students’ schedules and teacher assignments for not nearly enough gain.
Let’s continue distance learning until we have more widespread testing and/or a vaccine.
Let’s take a look at how the Los Altos District has woven in asynchronous learning.
With Gratitude,
Kerah Cottrell
Kim Lohse • Nov 13, 2020 at 10:18 pm
Middle school teachers were not included on any of these dialogues. We also have concerns.