NextDoor highlights Palo Alto’s privilege
When users open the Palo Alto feed on the neighborhood social networking site NextDoor, a multitude of posts pop up. Some seek advice. Some ask about the dining in the area. Some look for the best afterschool program. Aside from these queries, however, there are a surprising number of complaints, many of which are insignificant in regards to the greater good of the community.
While residents have the right to share grievances about their communities, there is a point where the constant negativity in the comments on NextDoor becomes toxic. The comments on the platform represent the bubble of privilege that Palo Alto exists in.
On any given day, posts on NextDoor can include a variety of complaints. People post about the smell from their neighbors using their firepit. Another user shares their annoyance about a dog getting too close to someone’s food at a park. Another post shares a complaint about children playing on the tennis courts. In many cases, these insignificant incidents would be forgiven with a simple exchange. But when people use the platform to voice their frustrations about such small annoyances, problems can be blown out of proportion.
These complaints represent the privilege that Palo Alto residents are accustomed to, as small incidents create more drama than they should. At times, people tend to lose perspective on how big their problems really are because they may not experience larger struggles in their everyday lives.
NextDoor shouldn’t be entirely abandoned as it provides a space for community members to share resources and ideas. However, constant complaining on the platform—often over small things—can create a negative atmosphere that can drown out positive posts. Instead, moderators on NextDoor should filter posts so that more relevant posts aren’t overwhelmed by more mundane complaints. Additionally, people should try to keep trivial rants contained in smaller groups—or just not post them at all—to avoid harmful discourse. NextDoor can still be a good resource when used properly.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Henry M. Gunn High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Senior Sophia Stern is The Oracle's business manager and social media editor for the 2021-2022 school year and has been on staff for three years. In her...
James • Jul 29, 2021 at 5:45 am
That’s good news, I love Palo Alto!
Karen • Jul 13, 2021 at 10:24 pm
I’m a lead for Nextdoor who recently posted a comment asking members to be tolerant of other people’s posts and not flag them because they simply disagree. In my primarily Democratic and older community, over a hundred responses concurred that ND had become very intolerant and my post was appreciated.
I used an example of a recently reported and deleted post about how a member removed a homeless encampment on private property. It was factual, not inflammatory and included an informative video by a well known journalist who covers homelessness. This is allowed per the Nextdoor regulations, and the video was appropriate. Of course an argumentative member decided to instigate an altercation. He asked what was the video the member had linked. After I linked the video for him, he berated me and several other members, then reported me to Nextdoor Admin.
Admin believed the instigator, did not actually look at the feed or my comments, and suspended MY account. I have sent an email asking why I was suspended. I called for tolerance, then was attacked. But I don’t really believe I will get a response. Nextdoor has no option to challenge an unwarranted suspension.
Do I believe that Nextdoor Admin is being run by young people without the maturity and objectivity to effectively handle bullies, trolls and instigators? Based on the thousands of complaints, I believe they are way over their heads in fairly dealing with interpersonal conflicts.
What is the long term effect? It is tearing neighbors and communities apart. What is, in concept, a great idea has become divisive and dysfunctional because of the immaturity and/or unprofessionalism of those running Nextdoor, IMHO.
As primary users of the site (older people) migrate off due to unchecked bullying and unfair retaliation, I suspect Facebook’s Neighborhoods will poach many of Nextdoor’s members.